Forum Topic

Dog kills cat

At about 12.30 yesterday afternoon our cat was killed by a local dog. Sitting on our front doormat watching the world go by – as he so often did – he was brutally and savagely attacked. By a dog that had chewed through a makeshift tether, escaped through a front door left open by builders, and gone walkabout around the neighbourhood. In fairness, its owners came round to apologise and say how sorry they were. That took courage and compassion, and they are almost as distraught as we are. And I’m sure their decision not to use their normal metal lead to tie the dog up while they went out will haunt them as it haunts us. Dogs have chased cats since time began, but on most occasions those encounters seem to be in a playful ‘let’s have some fun’ mode. Very seldom do they get out of hand, even if the dog is off its lead, (most cats give as good as they get!), and it must be very rare indeed for a dog to go this far. In the end, the size difference – and the fact that our cat was cornered in our doorway – brought about this awful ending.So a beautiful, gentle, friendly and intelligent cat has been suddenly and brutally taken from us. A cat that was almost human in the way he tried to understand what we were saying, and used to ‘bat’ at our fingers with his claws fully retracted so as not to scratch us. He enriched our lives so much for 14 years, and we already miss him terribly – especially given the nature of his death. He was well-known and well-loved up and down Goldsmith Avenue, and we know he will be missed by others too. And no matter how many times we are told by the dog’s owners that their dog is gentle and friendly and “has never chewed through his lead before” and “never chased cats”, we are – perhaps understandably – unconvinced. And, speaking personally, I have no idea how I will react if I ever see that dog in the area again.It clearly has a real issue with cats and, given the opportunity, may repeat his actions. So the purpose of this sad tale is partly cathartic (and thank you for allowing me that), but also to serve as a warning for other cat – and dog – owners in the area.Pets come into our lives asking very little of us and give us a wonderful and unconditional return. And whilst allowing them their freedom to roam, we also need to be mindful of the sometimes horrific consequences…

Paul Higham ● 5075d22 Comments

Thank you Dee for your kind words. I suspect in reality the dog probably IS gentle and friendly with humans - and possibly with other dogs - but just has a serious issue with cats.And, yes, the incident was reported to the police by the very kind passing dog-walker who witnessed the incident and then, with the help of a friend, 'captured' the dog in question and returned it to its owners. My next door neighbour and our builder then went the extra mile and put Jaz gently into one of our green boxes and called the RSPCA. They couldn't help of course but it, once again, highlights how kind people can be in diversity.The owners were so distraught themselves and were brave enough to knock on our door to talk to us (we might have reacted very differently after all), that to take 'police action' seems only to exacerbate an already upsetting and traumatic situation. And the reason the dog was tethered? Because the daughter was picking up Mum from hospital after post-cancer treatment. So you see, they have problems enough of their own...But I do take your point about the police - I guess they should ascertain if this dog is actually a bit of a loose cannon or not. It's ironic in the extreme that a fatal attack like this can happen to a cat with little or no publicity or consequence, and yet had the same thing happened - even much less viciously - to a child (or even an adult), the incident would make front-page news...Which is quite right and proper, of course. But ironic all the same.

Paul Higham ● 5075d

Firstly i would like to offer my sincere condolances to you and your family on your loss.  Pets are family to many people and loosing ones pet in any manor is distressing enough, i can not imaine the added emotions of a loss in such a way as what has happened with your cat and i can whole heartedly say, knowing the family of the dog, how deeply sorry they are for what has happened.I am going to aim the next part of my message to the responders of your thread as I am not trying to in anyway justify or deter any part of action that has come from this dog but i do feel that, having read some of the responses, although entitled to their opinion, need to respond to some comments on behalf of the family who own the dog.Just to confirm, the dog everyone is referring to is a greyhound.  I am not going to ‘bore’ everyone with information on the breed but I would like to point out  that greyhounds are considered to be in the ‘top 10 most gentle dog breeds’!  They are naturally kind in temperment, gentle, loyal, shy and naturally very good with people of ALL ages – especially children oh and funnily enough generally get on with both other dogs & cats!  If anyone believes otherwise or has heard differently they can ‘Google’ it or beter yet, ask a vet or an animal breeder.  This dog has been in the family for nearly 3 years, prior to that the owners had a greyhound for nearly 13 years and lived in the area for over 16 years  Not once have they encounterd a problem with a person or another animal. The owners daughter has a 1 year old and there has been no hint of an issue,. The family have extended family with lots of people rangeing from the ages of 3 moths to 91 years old and again, there has NEVER been a concern. The dog does not go out without a lead, the ONLY time he is let off a lead outside is in an enclosed park – The owner even has a muzzel for the dog for when he is off the lead in an enclosed park.The dog owners have a lead which actually came from switzerland and is generally used on larger, stronger breeds such as Burmese mountain dogs – Its is extra strength nylon and approved – sadly it is / was not ‘chew proof’.  The dog was only tied up as he was getting in the way of the builders and the owners daughter needed to collect the owner from the hospital so to prevent either a worker or the dog being hurt, it was the only option at that time.  For whatever reason – maybe the fact that the dog has never been tied up before  - We don’t know but either way, he managed to chew through his lead and must have run out the door which the bulders had left open.  Sadly we all know what happened then.  The police were called, The owner took reponsibility and apologised in person – I don’t know how many people would do that. The family of the dog do feel extremly awful with what has happened, they are just as shocked , saddened and confused and would do anything they could to turn back time.  I would also like to mention that the builders who were working in the owners house would like to apologise too, they feel awful as they blame themselves for leaving the door open, if they hadn’t none of this would have happened.As I said earlier, I am in no way trying to excuse or justify what has happened but I am going to ask some of the responders to re read what they have written because some of the comments are, to be frank, quite shameful!  Someone said ‘That dog sounds like an absoloute savage’ and another said the dog was ‘tied with a ribbon’! Where did that come from? There are other comments regarding cats killing birds and mice – but that’s ok apparently?  I am surprised that no one has thought to mention that an outdoor cat would be more at risk from being attacked by foxes or being hit by cars or even suggested, a statistical analysis on the number of missing cats (which seems to be a common occurance) to see if numbers are increasing and why that may be and to possibly suggest some ideas.  As a community, we should be supporting each other by discussing how we may prevent accidents like this happening in the future. Because that is what this tradgic event was, an accident!  Rather than ‘bitch’ and spread the ‘story’ with inaccurate information of what happened - This thread has become a 21st century ‘chinease whispers’! and is absoloutly absurd!  There are many stages of grief and anger is one of them, the owner of the cat has  every right to feel angst against the dog and the owner with justice too but to the other threaders, there is no reason to add fuel to the fire and start a vigilanti, this is going to help no one.  Both parties live in the area.  The owner of the dog, has had a horrible few years with her husband having a severe stroke and then herself having cancer.  They are both recovering and trying to get back into the world and now the owner is worried and feeling uncomforable about leaving the house for fear that she will ‘bump’ into one of you and end up being confronted.  Many people may not be happy with my words, for the owner of the cat, I apologise publicly if this or any part of this has added to your grief or offended you in any way.  That was and is not my intent.  I just felt that I had to make my voice heard and ask people that before they make a comment,  that you ensure 100% that you have the correct facts. 

Melinda Armitage-Rogers ● 5062d

Hi Melinda.  You're obviously a great friend and I'm so sorry to hear of the dog owner's troubles in recent times.  She really doesn't need this and I'm very sorry she feels she can't go out.  On that point, I'm really sure people aren't witch-hunting her or her dog.  It would be an awful shame to think that, and I'm sure it's not the case.I'm sorry you've felt the need to post and, if you don't mind my saying, I think it's a little over-reactive.  People have been very caring towards both the owner of the dog and the poor cat.  I also think it's fair to say that when a dog (or cat) corners its prey (a smaller animal than itself), it will indeed try to kill it.  Mostly the smaller animal can get away, thankfully.  Poor Jaz couldn't.  I'm sure your friend's pet is loving and gentle in the norm.  I really don't think the dog was doing anything that didn't come naturally, unfortunately.  My step-dad and Dad owned greyhounds and all kinds of dogs....unfortunately to hunt, illegal as it is.  In the right environment, they are wonderful pets.  When let loose to do what nature urges them to do, they are vicious.  Cats, dogs, foxes...all of them.  It's in their nature.  This doesn't single your friend's dog out at all.  I may have made things worse by posting this but that's not my intention.  My intention is to squash your friend's anxiety.  I don't think anyone is blaming her.  I adore all animals, especially dogs but I've also been around them long enough to know they can be vicious when the "need" or chance arises, but we love them just the same.  It's shocking when they do and sometimes deadly.I do hope your friend doesn't let this stop her from living her life and I wish her well.

Angela White ● 5061d

Perhaps as Jaz's 'owner', I could throw some oil on what appears to be becoming increasingly troubled waters.It has never been, and will never be, our intention to draw out this sad event any longer than needs be. And, for the record, we hold no malicious thoughts against the owners of the dog or their family and friends. We certainly don't want them to be ostracised or feel uncomfortable about walking their dog in the neighborhood - and I made a point of this when talking to the editor about the article posted on the home page of this site. We are hardly likely to welcome the dog into our home, but we are not seeking to do it - or them - any harm either. We are dog lovers ourselves, and both Rosie and I grew up surrounded by dogs and cats. Rosie's family in Ireland have three dogs and two cats at the moment, and have in the past had up to six dogs. So we do know about dogs - and cats - and what they do normally, and can do in extreme situations.People have been amazingly kind and supportive, and I'm sure that if any of their comments seem disproportionately severe, they are based on their emotional reaction to this incident rather than a reflection of any long-term character traits. As a family, we too have had more than our share of cancer over the last two-and-a-half years, so can empathise acutely with the stresses and emotional upheaval that that awful thing brings. So we apologise if, by posting on this site, we had added to their pain. That was never our intention. And although I remain firm in my views about the lack of owners' legal responsibility for the behaviour of their dogs, perhaps now it's time to let this particular post rest. We are coming to terms with Jaz's death and absence, and are moving on. As we must. And, whilst hopefully all learning lessons from this sad affair, I'd like to think that everyone else concerned can do the same.  --------------------------- Just for the record, and in answer to Melinda's question, the trailing 'lead' that was still around the dog's neck (and by which it was caught and again controlled), was described as a 'piece of ribbon' by the first person on the scene. If that description was incorrect, I apologise - it was probably me who first described it thus.

Paul Higham ● 5061d